${site.data.firmName}${SEMFirmNameAlt} Main Menu
Call Today: 855-805-0595

Court rules father is unnecessary complication during childbirth p2

14078142_S.jpgWhen the woman in this case decided that she did not want the father of her child in the delivery room with her, she may not have realized she was making new law. She was simply a mother-to-be who had broken up with her fiance shortly after she learned she was pregnant.

She knew he was the father, and she told the court that she would be amendable to him being notified when she went into labor, even to have him in a room adjacent to the delivery room so he could hold the newborn. She just didn't want him in the delivery room.

As we mentioned in our last post, she has helped to add a new dimension to how New Jersey's courts interpret and protect a woman's liberty interests and right to privacy. In some ways, the decision blends HIPAA's provisions governing the privacy of an individual's health care information with the woman's liberty interest in the birth of the child.

So, the court said that because it is the mother who carries the child, it is the mother's right to decide who may and may not be with her during delivery. Furthermore, as the U.S. Supreme Court noted in one of the cases relied on here, this is true even if the couple is husband and wife.

For father's rights advocates, the decision is a setback. With more couples choosing to have children outside of marriage, the court may have made it more difficult for fathers to be involved, to bond with the child at a critical stage. The ruling could very well undercut any progress advocates have made in advancing the rights of fathers to be more than support checks. We'll just have to wait and see if other courts rely on this decision to deny fathers custody, visitation or a meaningful role in his child's upbringing.

The mother in this case did allow the plaintiff, the father of her child, to hold the baby.

On another note, the court also held that "Paternity of a child cannot be simply established by placing a man's name on a birth certificate because a birth certificate does not constitute a legal finding of parentage, nor does it create rights." How this will affect existing New Jersey law is a subject for another post on another day.

Sources: 

The Christian Science Monitor, "N.J. judge cites women's rights in barring unwed dad from child's birth," Patrik Jonsson, March 12, 2014

Plotnick v. Deluccia, 2013 WL 7869380, N.J.Super.Ch., 2013 via Westlaw

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Contact Our Team To Get Help Now

Tell us about your case and we’ll get back to you promptly.

Bold labels are required.

ERROR: Please enter a site level or form specific email address in the application.

Contact Information
disclaimer.

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

close
Stange Logo

Stange Law Firm, PC
120 S. Central Avenue
Suite 450
St. Louis (Clayton), Missouri 63105

Toll Free: 855-805-0595
Fax: 314-963-9191
St. Louis Law Office Map

DHQ | Divorce Headquarters Divorce
Headquarters ® App Download The App
Questions? Live Chat Pay Your Bill Online
States of Service

Other Office Locations

  • Saint Louis County: 120 S. Central Ave., Suite 450, Clayton, MO 63105: Clayton Office
  • West County: 16024 Manchester Rd., Suite 103, Ellisville, MO 63011: Ellisville Office
  • Jackson County: 256 NE Tudor Rd., Lee's Summit, Missouri 64086: Lee's Summit Office
  • Jefferson County: 16 Municipal Drive, Suite C, Arnold, MO 63010: Arnold Office
  • St. Charles County: 2268 Bluestone Drive, St. Charles, MO 63303: St. Charles Office
  • Franklin County: 5 S. Oak St. Union, MO 63084: Union Office
  • Lincoln County: 20 Centerline Drive, Troy, Missouri 63379: Troy Office
  • Boone County: 1506 Chapel Hill Rd., Suite H, Columbia, MO 65203: Columbia Office
  • Greene County: 901 E. St. Louis, Suite 404, Springfield, Missouri 65806: Springfield, MO Office
  • St. Clair County: 115 Lincoln Place Ct., Ste. 101, Belleville, IL 62221: Belleville Office
  • Madison County: 25 Professional Park, Suite B, Maryville, Illinois 62062: Maryville Office
  • Sangamon County: 400 S. 9th St., Suite 100, Springfield, IL 62701: Springfield Office
  • McLean County: 1012 Ekstam Drive, Suite 4, Bloomington, IL 61704: Bloomington Office
  • Johnson County: 7300 West 110th Street, Suite 560, Overland Park, KS 62210: Overland Park Office
  • Sedgwick County: 2024 N. Woodlawn Street, Suite 407, Wichita, Kansas 67208: Wichita Office
  • Shawnee County: 800 SW Jackson Street, Suite 812, Topeka, Kansas 66612: Topeka Office
  • Tulsa County: 6660 S. Sheridan Road, Suite 240, Tulsa, Oklahoma 74133 Tulsa Office
  • Monroe County: 116 W. Mill St., Waterloo, IL 62298 (by appt. only): Waterloo Office
  • St. Louis City: 100 S. 4th St., #549, St. Louis, MO 63102 (by appt. only): St. Louis Office
  • Jackson County: 2300 Main St., #948, Kansas City, MO 64108 (by appt. only): Kansas City Office

The choice of a lawyer is an important decision & should not be based solely upon advertisements. See additional disclaimers here.